Turf War, Snagging Tarpon, and A Crash Course on Boca Grande Pass Etiquette by FWC

With all the talk about the Save The Tarpon movement being simply a turf war, you can’t help but acknowledge that there must be some validity in the argument.  There is some truth behind the accusations, but that truth may not be as clear as has been described.  There is no denying that which side of the pro-jig/anti-jig movement you fall on often has some correlation with where you live.  A vast majority of the jig guides and PTTS participants come to town for the months of May and June, and once the Tarpon head offshore to spawn, that same majority return home to either continue fishing in their home waters or pursue other occupations.  They have very little tie to the local community during the rest of the year. I don’t think there is any denying this fact by either side of the argument.

The notion that the fight over Boca Grande Pass Tarpon fishing is about a group of traditional  pass fishing guides wanting to stop all others from fishing in their “private fishing hole”  is the battle cry of most who oppose the Save The Tarpon movement.  However, nothing could be further from the truth.  This is absolutely a turf war, but not in the way so frequently described by participants of the Professional Tarpon Tournament Series and board members of the Florida Guides Association.

FWC at PTTS Protest  - Save the Tarpon

FWC overlooks the PTTS weigh boat during the June 17th protest.

The fact is that the jig fishing “pack” is supported primarily by the PTTS and the Florida Guides Association.  These two groups often point fingers at the Boca Grande Fishing Guides Association as being behind the Save The Tarpon movement, and proclaim that they are looking to exclude jig fishermen from the Pass because the jig fishermen are “stealing their charter business.”  How can this be the case when you have a grassroots movement, not yet sixty days old, that has more than seventeen hundred supporters? A number that grows by an average of thirty per day.  At last count the Boca Grande Fishing Guide Association had less than fifty paying members, could they be the sole purveyors of such compelling “propaganda” as the Florida Guides Association representatives love to call it?  Could the Boca Grande Fishing Guides Association really “brainwash” that many folks on a regular basis?  Even if they could pull off that feat, could they do so with some of the most experienced and well respected fishermen in Florida, and nation wide?

There are some facts in the arguments levied by the PTTS, Florida Guides Association, and its supporters that need some clarification.  First off, the “authorities” on jig fishing related information that they love to reference are not in fact the first generation of jig fishermen, they are the second.  There was a time when Capt. Dave Markett, one of the most outspoken supporters of the jig fishery, Florida Guides Association West Florida Representative, and self proclaimed jig fishery expert, was struggling to keep up with the likes of Captains Ed  Walker and Chris Klingel. These two were not only catching a LOT more fish on charters, but they were also sweeping nearly every tarpon tournament throughout the year.  That’s sweeping, not just winning.  As a matter of fact, those two talented individuals account for more total dollars of winnings between them then every single first place prize from the PTTS to date combined!  Where are the two ‘kings’ of the jig fishery now?  Well they quit jig fishing long ago of course.  They both have also spoken out against the jig fishery and the PTTS.  But wait, weren’t those people who were against the jig fishery and the PTTS only holding firm to that position because the “experts” in the jig fishery were more successful?  Why then would the two most successful jig captains in history, financially speaking, choose to hang up their beloved tiger shad?  They both seem to think that the jig is nothing more than a snagging device, and that the jig fishery in general is damaging  Boca Grande pass both biologically and socially.  Whats their motivation?  If I answered it would only be conjecture, maybe Capt. Markett should ask them.

So if people are not coming out against the PTTS because of money lost, then why are so many speaking out against it and rallying for not only an end to the tournament but often to the jig fishery as a whole?  The answer here is both extremely complex and exceedingly simple.

The only real supporters of the PTTS and the jig fishery are its participants, owners, sponsors, and the Florida Guides Association.  This is a fairly small group of individuals with a common interest in that they all benefit financially, either directly or indirectly, from the PTTS.  The same cannot be said for the group rallying behind the Save The Tarpon movement, as they are much more diverse group of individuals, with even more diverse interests both financially and socially. Although some are fishing guides or make their living upon the waters of Florida, very few have a financial stake in the game.  This group claims that the PTTS, and correspondingly the jig fishery as it has evolved to date, is causing irreparable harm both biologically and socially to the Boca Grande Tarpon Fishery.  How exactly they are causing these problems is where we start to get into the complexity as not all members or supporters of the movement seem to agree.  They all agree that there is a problem and the PTTS and the jig fishermen are damaging the fishery, but they do not agree on exactly how or why.

The effects of culling out large females, handling them excessively and, as the state and all conservation oriented groups describe as “inappropriately” during the Professional Tarpon Tournament Series has been discussed at length.  For now we will leave that argument to rest as we should not lose sight of the other half of the problem at hand and the crux of the argument against the jig fishery as a whole.

Some say that the jig does nothing more than snag fish.  This is an argument supported not solely by the traditional pass fishermen of the Boca Grande Fishing Guides Association, but also by many of the most winning captains ever to fish with a jig in Boca Grande History.  As a matter of fact, you will not find ANY of the original guides or participants who were instrumental in bringing the jig to Boca Grande Pass and perfecting its use still using the jig today.

The assertion that the jig snags fish, that they are not actually choosing to eat the jig, means that users of said jig are able to aggressively pursue tarpon to a point at which they are more attacking the fish than they are coaxing them to bite. If they had to rely on the fish to actually open its mouth and bite the jig, this hyper aggressive pursuit would prove fruitless.  Case in point, during nearly all times when the jig is yielding a nearly instant hookup, it will prove virtually impossible to catch a Tarpon on anything else regardless of the skill of the captain, the type of bait or lure, or the way in which it is rigged.  If the fish are feeding so aggressively, how can this be so?  Anglers supporting the use of the jig have come up with a myriad of explanations, but none has yet proven to take hold as the official position of the PTTS or the Florida Guides Association.

A 2002-2004 hook placement study, conducted by the significant other of one of the most high profile participants of the PTTS at the time, proved “inconclusive”.  The findings did not vindicate the jig as a snagging device, but did not find sufficient evidence to ban the jig in its entirety.  Remember the FWC is a reactive agency, not proactive.  Mote Marine Laboratory holds a similar position as their official statement is that “more research is required.”

So at this point we are stuck.  We have anecdotal evidence presented by the most experienced among the jig fishermen, as well as  the most winning captains ever to use a jig stating it is nothing more than a snagging device.  On the other hand we  have the current participants of the PTTS, Florida Guides Association representatives, and jig fishing guides saying it does not.  The data to this point has proved “inconclusive” and there is even question as to what exactly constitutes a “foul hooked” Tarpon.  So we are at a bit an impasse.  But is this the whole argument?

If it were simply about snagging or foul hooking a fish in the corner of the jaw, the reactions of participants on both sides would not be so visceral.  AfterBoca Grande Tarpon Fishingall, if one hooks a  fish’s mouth from the outside in, or the inside out does it really make such a large difference in the fish’s survival that guides on both sides of the fence will literally come to blows over it?  Absolutely not!  So why is the battle so heated?  Could it be that there is a little more to the story than just a shift in charter business and overcrowding?

Here we are, back at the complexity of why so many people, from so many walks of life, with so many diverse interests in the fishery and community of Boca Grande are rallying together to fight the PTTS and some say, the jig fishery as a whole.  We often get lost in the complexity of this argument, and at times it seems so complex that proponents of the jig jump to no other conclusion than it is all a farce played out by traditional pass fishermen looking to exclude everyone else from fishing in Boca Grande Pass.  While this may or may not be their agenda (I am not, nor have I ever been a member), it is becoming increasingly clear that this is absolutely a turf war where one user group is excluding all others. However, the description of this turf war has been a bit skewed by those looking to protect a significant stream of income they derive both directly and indirectly from the jig fishery at Boca Grande Pass.  It is the PTTS, Florida Guides Association board members, and the jig fishery guides who are effectively excluding all other fishers from pursuing Tarpon in and around Boca Grande Pass during daylight hours in May and June.

Boca Grande Pass is a very congested place during May and June, and rightfully so.  It offers Tarpon fishing opportunities that are not found elsewhere in North America.  Unfortunately this is not a problem of simple overcrowding, as that would be a much less heated and easier solved debate.  Rather, it is a problem of a culture of disrespect that has become synonymous with the Professional Tarpon Tournament Series and the jig fishery as a whole. Disrespect not only for the fish and fellow fishermen, but also for the community, its inhabitants, and its heritage.  That is not to say that everyone who jig fishes or participates in the PTTS is guilty, but rather refers to the actions of the group as a whole.

No other fishery specifically excludes others from their pursuit of Tarpon in Boca Grande Pass. The relentless, hyper-aggressive pursuit of tarpon while jig fishing is having obvious and devastating affects on other sectors of the fishery.  Further, once these fish leave the pass, these same aggressive and exclusionary tactics carry over to other areas of the fishery, compounding the issue dramatically.  For lack of a better term, no place is safe from the invasion of the horde when the fish leave the pass.  Could the pass and the surrounding fishery support the number of boats currently fishing? Absolutely.  But as the numbers of fishermen and boats increase, and correspondingly pressure increases on the fish, successful continuation of the fishery relies upon increased cooperation among participants in the fishery.  The jig fishery as a whole represents the antithesis to this very need.

So why do we have such a large and diverse group calling for an end to the PTTS?  To put it simply, the PTTS has created and fostered the disrespect for the fishery, its history, and culture. It can be seen publicly from the lowest level participant to the top rungs of management and ownership. Just as the scraps of what once were magnificent fish wash away upon the outgoing tide after each PTTS event, so too will the Boca Grande tarpon fishery as a whole disappear once the respect for the fishery, the community, and the fish are lost, only to be replaced by a relentless pursuit of increased revenue.

Why are many among the Save the Tarpon movement also calling for an end to the jig fishery as a whole?  I cannot speak for all of them, but the consensus among them is that this fishery means to much to us as a community and as the fishing public to be denied access to the fishery by a small group of individuals who are out simply to pad their pocketbook.  Is it a turf war? Absolutely.  The PTTS and the jig fishery are fighting to maintain the strangle hold they have had on Boca Grande Pass for the last decade, and they can feel it slipping away.  The charade is coming to an end, and too many questions and accusations are being levied by too many people for it to continue to simply be ignored.  How large will our numbers have to grow before they stop claiming our actions are those of a small group of local traditional guides seeking to secure a financial interest in Boca Grande Pass?  How long will they cling to the historic slaughter of Tarpon at Boca Grande Pass at the hands of the traditional guides years ago as justification for their own slaughter they commit each and every weekend in May and June to this very day?  How long will they continue to ignore the pleas of conservation minded anglers and organizations to stop what they are doing? Will it take closing Boca Grande Pass to all tournaments or even all fishing in May and June as so many among their ranks have claimed?  Maybe it will, I don’t claim to be an expert, only to have my own informed opinion.

I leave with a parting gift.  The following excerpt was taken from the current FWC brochure published on Tarpon Fishing at Boca Grande Pass.  Keep in mind the arguments of those against the jig fishery when you read the following. The next time you watch the PTTS on TV or happen to be driving through the pass in May or June  ask yourself “are these the actions of the jig fishery participants?”  Maybe you will begin to see why the PTTS, Florida Guides Association, and the jig fishery as a whole have all other user groups of the Tarpon fishery so upset.

Taken from http://myfwc.com/media/2077379/Tarpon_brochure.pdf

 

Tarpon Biology

The majority of tarpon caught in Boca Grande Pass are of reproductive age; therefore, extra care should be taken when handling these fish so they remain healthy to spawn and produce the next generation of tarpon. Practicing good conservation and fishing ethics when tarpon fishing will help ensure a sustainable tarpon population.

Safe Boating and Pass Etiquette

• Operate your boat at a rate of speed that does not create a wake.
• When approaching the fleet make note of the direction of drift, and begin your drift at the head of the pack (up-current side).
• When finishing a drift, move to the head of the fleet by going around, not through the fleet.
• Boat operators should always avoid interfering with another boat’s drift.
• Do not rush over or chase a school of tarpon you see rolling at the surface.
• Do not run through a school of tarpon. Go around them and start your fishing in front of the school.

The same FWC that owners of the PTTS falsely claimed “support” their event seems to realize there is a need for etiquette among fishermen in the pass in order to avoid conflicts. I guess these only apply to everyone  who is a not a “professional” in the Tarpon Tournament Series.

Comments

  1. says

    Gary Colecchio, Southwest Florida spokesperson for the Florida Guides Association writes:

    “Captain McLaughlin finally acknowledges that this controversy is precisely what everyone observing this understands it to be, a turf war and admits to taking the traditional live bait guides side. That is all it was and all it will be.”

    Well Mr. Colecchio, maybe you should read this article one more time before you begin quoting me and commenting on my intent.

    1) This is a turf war. It is about the PTTS and the jig fishery claiming Boca Grande Pass as THEIR TURF and excluding all other citizens from all other uses of the pass during the months of May and June. This goes not only for traditional Tarpon fishing, but all fishing including Tarpon, Grouper, Snapper, Mackerel, etc.

    2) Though your arrogance may not allow you to spend the time to properly educate yourself on the specifics of what happens in BGP, you yourself described the extent of your expertise to be having visited BGP “4 or 5 times” perhaps you should withhold your ‘expert’ opinion until such time as you have actually seen what goes on at BGP on a regular basis in May and June. There absolutely is a usergroup conflict, but there is more to this than just Jig Vs. traditional live bait. Our ogranization represents “everyone else” for lack of a better term. The PTTS and the jig fishery do a fine job of alienating all fishermen who are not participants in their fishery. Suddenly all of the other usergroups who have been excluded are finding a unified voice, this obviously has you and your cronies at the PTTS and Florida Guides Association worried, but not worried enough to actually answer the allegations levied against the PTTS, its participants, and the Jig fishery it has created. The lying, the hiding, and the exlusion of the public from its own resource for the financial gain of a small group of individuals has come to light, causing the PTTS to the bear the brunt of the public displeasure it has created through its own actions.

    3) If this is all about the “live baiters and nothing more, nor will ever be anything more”, I would be curious as to why so many highly respected individuals representing such a diverse list of user groups have come forward to support and further this cause? Could it be one giant conspiracy to help the less than 40 paying members of the BGFGA to take of the Boca Grande Pass?

    4) If brainwashing the fishing and non-fishing public is so simple, why have the extensive efforts of the board members of the Florida Guides Association who are tied to the PTTS resulted in a showing of support from only a handful of participants of the PTTS? Where is the public showing of support by individuals without a financial interest in the tournament? Where is the support from other user groups opposed to the BGFGA hostile takeover you speak so frequently about? Where are the business owners coming forward to show their support of the jig fishery and the PTTS in order to protect the “millions of dollars flowing into the local community from the PTTS?”

    The charade is coming to end, and Florids Guides Association representatives Markett, Colecchio, Mercurio, and Sapp are helping to expose the PTTS for what it really is, not as a conservation oriented show of sportsmanship, but rather a for-profit, made for TV series concerned solely with its own revenue regardless of its impacts on the fishery, the community, or its inhabitants.

  2. c raig heser says

    I tend to agree that what is happening in Boca is in part a turf war… wether on land or on the water , as a high level of greed and a bunch of pompass asses , tend to ruin things for evryone , turf wars never solve any thing , and somewhere in that war something always pays the price , in this case… the Tarpon pay the price , and down the road we will all pay the price of having our fisheries destoyed.
    Until all those in question get there heads out of their asses , and start working together to save these great fish and all of our fisheries , we can all just stand there and watch it all disapear , or we can all contribute what ever we can to turn this situation around and get it headed in the right direction !!

  3. Tom Rook says

    This article is the apex of the STT campaign, if you can’t read this and feel any understanding towards what this movement is about then you are blinded by ignorance.

    And Gary Colecchio, you are the very reason why I don’t even bother browsing the Florida Sportsman forum any more. You feed off any negativity, you push the real argument to the side and spitefully twist a discussion into a pointless cluster, you fail to differentiate right from wrong and your constant immature behaviour is embarrassing. And the irony of it all, as a ‘KEY’ former district director of DOEP, how can you not accept that what’s going on in the pass is even slightly damaging?

    You really need to grow up, Gary. This isn’t about a group of anglers fighting for elbow room in the pass, this is about protecting a prehistoric fish, it’s that simple. Accept it, get off your high horse and sit down.

  4. Kalee says

    It is NOT a turf war, it is about catching Tarpon that actually bite the hook. The Jig needs to stop, period. It is not about “jiggers” taking over the pass. The repercussions of the jigs and the snagging that hurts the fish. Boca Grande Pass is the only area in the United States were Tarpon come to feed, rest, and get ready to spond. Numbers have significantly decreased. I am against the PTTS as well as jig fishing. This style of fishing has accomplished nothing and is negatively effecting our ecosystem. If the jigging and PTTS continues, you might as well kiss Tarpon fishing goodbye. Our fishery will be gone. So thank you to all “jiggers” and PTTS participants.

  5. Bruce Davis says

    Hey, next tournament, get everyone that has a sailboat and sail right through the pack all day. The pass is a marked channel, and boats under power are required to give way to boats under sail. Think that might disrupt their little show?

  6. says

    Please don’t call snaggers, jiggers. I’ve recently learned they use a jig to disguise the fact that they are snagging. But they are snagging and they are not jigging. I use jigs to trick fish of all kinds of shapes and sizes into biting. I strongly prefer artificial to live bait to environmental and convenience reasons. I would never snag a fish.

    Thanks.

    • Charles Veres says

      I am concerned about the FWC getting involved. No cop and no legislator ever saw a tack he couldn’t drive with a sledgehammer. As NaiveLocal points out, jigging (brightly colored lure less than 1 oz.) is a popular and effective technique. Once the cops get involved, this may be outlawed statewide.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *